Dichotomies

A dichotomy is pitting one thing against another. Two things. No more, no less. One or the other. Ain't no option C.

I like dichotomies. The problem with them is that they are often false. A false dichotomy is a problem with one of the lines of reasoning, or (usually) that truly a third option exists yet out of the thinker's grasp which best sums up the possibilities of a situation.

Here's a good example of a false dichotomy.

Assuming "a god-force" created the universe, humans exist.
Humans are wicked, as a result of something.
This earth, as a result, is full of corruption.

If this "god" is powerful, why does he not stop the evils?
If this "god" is merciful, why doesn't he try or seem to want to? 

(Actually, I don't like that one. It fails too easily, and I can't really distinguish the two options.)

I'll just use the "Problem of Sin" as an example instead.

a. Assuming the Christian viewpoint of creation, life, the universe, and everything,
b. GOD is almighty
c. and loving.
d. Sin exists.

The un-believer concludes that either
1. God ain't all powerful, since sin and the effects of the fall obviously aren't contained to this day (snort.) OR
2. God ain't all good, since a good God would want to clean up ALL the messes and stop ALL bad things, right?
when really the third option is the best fit with reality:
3. GOD Almighty is strong and loving, therefore He has a good and powerful reason for sin to be.